One Bad Egg Spoils the PR Bunch

by Gradon on February 23, 2010 · View Comments

in Marketing,Public Relations,blogging

Some bloggers are difficult to pitch. I hear stories about how some bloggers won’t write about a product or service unless someone they’ve already met in person, or have a relationship of some sort through social media, suggests it to them. If you’re new or relatively unknown, good luck getting their attention.

I’m not that hard to pitch. If you send me an email that matches the niche of my site — in my case, Boston-area architecture and design — and shows some degree of originality or something interesting about you, I’m probably going to write about you.

An email I received today breaks even my generous threshold for what’s acceptable.

PR Failure

First, and most important, he got my name wrong. If Andrew even bothered to read a post, or the “About” page, he would know who he was addressing in his email. Do just a little homework and you’ll be in an infinitely better position than Andrew here.

Second, he gives no information about his company beyond a name and website. How are you going convince someone that your product is worthwhile if you don’t tell them anything? It’s an old saying, but it’s true: Tell a story, explain how you’re unique, better. If you don’t tell people, how are they going to know?

Third, he tries to bribe me. I have no problem with reviewing a product (so long as any prior arrangement is properly disclosed), or even arranging a contest, giveaway or other such benefit for a blog’s audience. But to just throw out “I have cash and merchandise available” reeks of a lack of class.

I know this isn’t the norm. This isn’t what the top speakers in public relations and blogger outreach promote. But I can only guess at how many similar emails Andrew sent out, and fear for what that says about the company he represents — and the industry he works in.

  • megfowler

    I get bizarre pitches because no one is quite sure how to classify me as a blogger. I get mommyblogging ones (I have no kids), I get technology ones (I love tech, but I don't blog about it)… I even got one on a major development in aeronautics directed at a Meg Flower.

    Dude. It's not tough to spend ten minutes seeing if the pitch fits. And checking to make sure you spelled my name properly.

  • http://www.twitter.com/jennalyns Jennalyns

    I saw the tweet and thought, “Please don't let it be from our PR company. Please don't let it be from our PR company.” A. Glad it wasn't. B. Bad sign I thought there was a chance it could be.

  • http://ijasmin.posterous.com/ Jasmin

    I just don't understand why anyone would make that awful mistake about names. People adding an 'e' to Jasmin is enough for me to hit the delete button!

  • http://www.gradontripp.com gradontripp

    In life, I've learned to ignore people addressing me as Gordon – close enough, I guess. But Robert? Someone copy and pasted without thinking.

  • http://www.gradontripp.com gradontripp

    The unfortunate thing is, you know how bad your agent is, but do the people that hired (and pays) them? It seems agents bad performance — the genesis of your cringing — doesn't reach that far up.

  • dirkler

    Even with my mom and pop music blog (that barely ever reviews new artists) I still get a ton of awful emails from music PR firms (with comcast or hotmail accounts). You can tell they were just blasted out with 'fill in name of site here' then hit send.

    But the other day I got one from an artist in Berlin who started with the same method as everyone else, yet took one tiny different approach that made all the difference in the world. He commented about a specific post on my blog. What a shocking notion. He did his homework and didn't make it all about himself.

    Moral of the story? I listened. I loved. He get a quick response. And look for a very cool piece on my mom and pop blog about Jim Kroft coming soon :)

  • http://www.gradontripp.com gradontripp

    Exactly! It's not that difficult, and it sets you so far apart from your competition.

    BTW, I originally read the beginning of your comment, “with my mom, and pop-music blog.” I was confused. :)

  • http://www.twitter.com/jennalyns Jennalyns

    There's a LOT that doesn't reach that far up…

  • dirkler

    You think I'm Pitchfork or Rolling Stone here?? I could probably grab a beer with any one of my readers. And sadly I really like it that way.

  • http://www.gradontripp.com gradontripp

    There's nothing sad about keeping it small, so long as you're happy, right?

  • http://www.worob.com/ Worob

    makes you wonder if this is an independent PR person, someone at an agency, in-house, or maybe someone at a company that has zero PR background?

    @Worob
    PR at Sunrise blog – worob.com

  • http://www.worob.com/ Worob

    makes you wonder if this is an independent PR person, someone at an agency, in-house, or maybe someone at a company that has zero PR background?

    @Worob
    PR at Sunrise blog – worob.com

blog comments powered by Disqus

Previous post:

Next post: